Written By: Registered Dietitian Mairead
As a dietitian, this is a very common question I get: how much should I weigh?
While this seems like a straight-forward question, it's often more complicated than we'd think.
You could pull out a calculator and figure out how much you should weigh for your height according to the Body Mass Index (BMI). This will give you a theoretical range, but BMI doesn't take variations in how much muscle people have. With our training at Degree, we often see people put on muscle and lose body fat, but their weight stays the same. The BMI equation can't account for this because it's simply just an equation.
BMI also isn't accurate for tall people, short people, and many different cultural groups.
Theoretically, technically, and temporarily, we could diet ourselves down to be almost any weight we want. But long-term weight maintenance is more complicated than that. Temporary weight changes often just take into account calories in and calories out. Long-term changes have to consider the impact on your metabolism, what your lifestyle looks like, how often you can actually exercise, your favourite foods, who cooks at home, your grocery budget, social events... the list goes on!
Your best weight is the one you can maintain without a fight, but where you're still looking after your body.
What exactly that weight is might change through the different seasons of your life, whether that includes an injury, growing your family, or a change in job.
Your best weight includes eating satisfying amounts of foods you love, as well as making eating decisions that support your long-term health. It includes moving your body in ways that feel good, and moving your body often enough to maintain a level of fitness that lets you enjoy your life the way you want.
When we add or take away something from our life in the pursuit of health or a change in weight, there might be a trade off. Getting in extra workouts might mean going to bed earlier and therefore less TV in the evening. Does that fit with how you want to live your life right now? Going on a restrictive diet might mean less eating out with friends, more time in the kitchen, and less of your favourite foods. Are those trade-offs you want to make? There's no right or wrong answer, just deciding what matters to you.
Finally, contrary to what social media would have you believe, there is more to your body size and weight than just how much you exercise and how you eat.
Your body's specific and unique physiology plays a huge role too, and one we usually can't override completely. This includes genetics, your stress levels and the impact that has on your body, and your current metabolism. Other factors could include socioeconomic status and history, dieting history, and any underlying medical conditions.
Keeping all of this in mind, here's my answer to what your healthiest weight is:
Your healthiest weight at this time is the one where you are eating and moving in ways that feel good and are promoting overall health without taking away from other important parts of your life or sacrificing your mental health.
If you're looking to learn more about how we can work some nutrition changes into your life to help you be your happiest and healthiest self at your best weight, let's chat more.
Nutrition Consultations and On-Going Nutrition Coaching are not available at this time, but you can join the waitlist to be first in line when spots open up. To join the waitlist or to learn more, email
mairead@degreefitnessseaforth.com!